何文藻醫師發表狐臭手術於美國皮膚外科Dermatologic surgery 國際期刊




My name is Jacob Wen-Tsao Ho. I am dermatologist in Taiwan practicing in my own private clinic. Thank you for having me here. I would like to present My new concepts in osmidrosis surgery

Let me briefly introduce you the anatomy of sweat gland. Human has two kind of sweat glands. One is eccrine gland which is everywhere in the body, directly open to the surface and is responsible for the sweat secretion. The other is apocrine gland which is bigger and visible and attached to the follicle located in axillary area and responsible for the malodor.

認識狐臭? 一般來說人的體味大概可以分成兩大類:一個就是汗臭味,一個就是狐臭味。基本上藉著簡單的理學檢查,就可以分辨這兩個味道。一般來說,狐臭有一股特別的味道,在理學檢查的時候,患者通常可以發現有濕耳朵的情形。在生理的結構上,我們的汗腺可以分成兩種:一個就是小汗腺,小汗腺就像毛線球一樣,互相纏繞,最後它的管子會直通到表皮,主要是將汗水排出體外,所以當我們在運動或者是體溫比較高的時候,我們就會藉著小汗腺將汗水排出來,達到調控體溫的作用。小汗腺的分布基本上廣布在全身的表皮上面。另外一個叫做大汗腺,大汗腺又叫做頂漿腺。它的分布只侷限在如腋下或者是跨下等,所以頂漿腺它主要是分泌一種特殊的脂肪酸,這些脂肪酸經過細菌酵素的催化以後,就會產生一股濃郁特殊的臭味,我們簡稱叫狐臭。

Differential diagnosis between hyperhidrosis and osmidrosis ==PE : wet earwax, body malodor
Treatment included non-invasive antiperpiratant , fragrance, botox, Nd-Yag, Radiofrequency, microwave thermolysis (Miradry), surgical intervention: liposonix , subdermal trimming, liposuction curettage , curettage

非侵入式: 體香劑,止汗劑,Nd-Yag雷射,微波熱分解Miradry
侵入式: 微創狐臭手術,旋轉刀刮除,傳統手術等等

I would like to share my 4 article accepted in 2016 by international journals of MJD from Malaysia, dermatologic surgery from US, JPRAS for UK and IJSSP for India.
1. (馬來西亞期刊)Malay journal of dermatology Genotyping at the SNP rs17822931 can help the clinical diagnosis of body malodor in doubt
2. (美國期刊)Dermatologic surgery Following Changes in the Axillary Secretions of Two Patients Before and After Bromhidrosis Surgery Using Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry. Ho WT, Lee LJ, Pan JY. Dermatol Surg. 2016 Sep 28.
3. (英國期刊)Reply “A comparison of two different sub-dermal trimming techniques for the treatment of axillary osmidrosis”. Ho WT. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2016 Jun 16

第一篇 關於狐臭診斷的問題

A 37-year old patient has a chief complaint of over perspiration and body odor for a length of time and has been bothered by it. This is especially during summer or after strenuous exercise. These problems have seriously affected his personal relationships with others and the opposite sex. He had consulted many doctors who then had different diagnosis, from acidity of his sweat and body odor. At times, he would use antiperspirant, which gave some relief. The patient lost confidence because of different diagnosis from different doctors, and he was being bothered by his odor that had caused him to lose his self-esteem. How to do?

大部分有狐臭的患者到門診,有經驗的醫師通常可以給予正確的診斷,藉著嗅聞患者的腋下味道,問診上可能搭配濕耳朵wet ear-wax增加佐證,或者家族中有明顯的遺傳證據,就可以輕易地決定是否可以接受狐臭手術。但是在案例眾多的裡面,我們仍然會遇到診斷上不是那麼容易,或者是模稜兩可的情形。最多混淆的情形就是多和造成的汗臭味或者是狐臭,因此對於下一步的治療上,會對臨床醫師造成困擾。

According to literature, Yoshiura et al. publised that a SNP, 538G > A (rs17822931), in the ABCC11 gene, can determine the dry or wet type of the earwax. The AA genotype corresponds to dry earwax, and the GA and GG to wet type. The strong association between the wet earwax-related genotypes (GG and GA) and bromhidrosis suggest SNP genotype can be a good marker for the diagnosis of bromhidrosis.

目前有許多的文獻告訴我們溼耳朵和基因有很強的相關性,而臨床上溼耳朵和狐臭又有很強的關聯性。我們針對他基因檢查有SNP rs1782291的Genotype,有此佐證則加強了狐臭的診斷,建議患者做狐臭手術,若沒有則建議單純處理多汗的問題。

雖然大部分的狐臭患者伴有濕耳朵(耳屎是濕的)現象,但這只能說兩者具相關性卻不能作為診斷的工具。醫學的發展雖然日新月異,針對這類病人,大部分臨床醫師在診斷上卻沿用了最古老直接的方式〜〜聞聞看。雖然很方便但準確度實在不夠精確。所以針對那些無法100%確認自己是否患有狐臭的患者,狐臭基因檢測(SNP rs17822931 in the ABCC11 gene)。

Sequencing chromatogram of the sample indicated AG heterozygous

Although the mutation found in this report is not novel, we would like to emphasize genetic studies can further help in the diagnosis of patients with a strong family history or whose diagnosis is in doubt.

As many of you know, lots of bromhidrosis surgery studies can be found on the PUBMED. Try doing searches on either osmidrosis or recurrence, you will find quite a lot, talked about relapse rate but few uses objective and quantitative way to define what the recurrence is; is it simply the smell called by one or the others?
So, that’s the reason behind my study and I would like to share with you all of my findings.

因為當我們上PUBMED上閱讀關於狐臭手術,您會發現有很多談到關於”復發”比率,簡單用osmidrosis (狐臭)和recurrence (復發)做搜尋,你會發現有很多文章提到recurrence(復發)。可是我們卻很少有一個客觀定量的方式去表明何謂 recurrence(復發),是主觀上有一點點的味道或全然的味道出現稱為復發?或是客觀上被聞到叫復發? 我們也不知道復發的嚴重情形是如何?

This article referred to comparing the recurrence rate of two procedures, but we do not know how to accurately compare the smell. Based on the above factors, I would like to find a quantitative measurement for surgeons so that each has a scientific communication platform.


The 2 patients ran on a treadmill for 20 min at room temperature for 3 consecutive days before surgery and 2 months and 6 months after surgery. Factors such as room temperature, mood, and body condition were controlled. The bilateral armpits were washed repeatedly with a total of 5 mL distilled water on each side, and the water and sweat were collected together. The specimens collected on the 3 consecutive days before surgery were combined, leaving three pools for analysis: before, 2 months after, and 6 months after surgery. Surgical satisfaction was also measured.

Perhaps you might ask why use 5cc of distilled water to rinse the armpits
If pre-surgery is x, and post-generate y, the molecule concentration before surgery is x/5cc; same thing goes for post-surgery (y/5cc). Which means the proportion is still divided between x and y.
It wouldn’t matter much water used, as long as the same amount of the water use for pre and post operation; more flushing water used, the more we can ignore the sweat volume effect.

或許你會問為何用5cc蒸餾水去沖洗腋下,如果術前是x,術後產生y,術前的味道分子濃度 x/5cc,術前的味道分子濃度 y/5cc,兩者相除比例仍為x/y


We aimed to evaluate these physiological changes in patients Using Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry. Apocrine gland secretions contain many odorous fatty acids, including linear saturated, linear unsaturated, and branched unsaturated C6-C11 acids.1, 2 Here, we measured (E)-3-methyl-2-hexenoic acid (3M2H), a C7 branched unsaturated fatty acid found in human apocrine gland secretions that has a particularly strong stench, especially in Caucasians and Asians

~~~~~the 3M2H change on the 1st patient.
Pre-OP: 223,796 (two hundred twenty-three thousands, seven hundred and ninety-six) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 3,069 (three thousand and sixty-nine) caps, a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up a little to 13,154 (thirteen thousand one hundred and fifty four) caps; slight increase from four month ago.
~~~~the HMHA change on the 1st patient.
Pre-OP: 658,062 (six hundred fifty-eight thousands and sixty-two) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 9,284 (ninety-two hundred and eighty-four) caps, a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up to 41,544 (forty-one thousand five hundred and forty-four) caps; an increase of 3.5% from four month ago.
~~~~ the 3M3SH change on the 1st patient.
Pre-OP: 102,965 (one hundred and two thousands, nine hundred and sixty-five) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 1,367 (thirteen thousand and sixty-seven) caps, a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up a little to 5,352 (five thousand three hundred and fifty two) caps; slight increase from four month ago.

兩位患者的追蹤 質譜儀下的狐臭分子變化
這是第一位患者的3M2H變化,術前223796 cps ,術後兩個月 3069 cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月 13154 cps(和術前比降低了94%),六個月比兩個月有微微的回升
HMHA變化,術前658062 cps ,術後兩個月 9284cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月 41544 cps(和術前比降低了93%);六個月比兩個月有微微的回升
患者的3M3SH變化,術前102695 cps ,術後兩個月 1367 cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月 5352 cps(和術前比降低了94%);六個月比兩個月有微微的回升


the 2nd patient.
Pre-OP: 229,932 (two hunThis is the 3M2H change on the 2nd patient.
Pre-OP: 53,976 (fifty-three thousands, nine hundred and seventy-six) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 864 (eight hundred and sixty-four) caps; a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up a little to 6,271 (sixty-two hundred and seventy-one) caps; a decrees of 88% compare to pre-op.
the HMHA change on dred twenty-nine thousand, nine hundred and seventy-six) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 4,810 (forty-eight hundred and ten) caps; a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up a little to 35,604 (thirty-five thousand, six hundred and four) caps; a decrees of 86% compare to pre-op.
This is the 3M3SH change on the 2nd patient.
Pre-OP: 6,451 (six thousands, four hundred and fifty-one) caps
2 months after the surgery, dropped down to 67 (sixty-seven) caps; a decrees of 98% compare to pre-op.
But, six month after the surgery, the number went up a little to 550 (five hundred and fifty) caps; a decrees of 91% compare to pre-op.


患者的3M2H變化,術前53976 cps ,術後兩個月 864cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月 6271 cps(和術前比降低了88%),六個月比兩個月有微微的回升;
患者的HMHA變化,術前229932cps ,術後兩個月 4810 cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月 35604 cps(和術前比降低了86%),六個月比兩個月有微微的回升
3M3SH變化,術前6451 cps,術後兩個月 67cps (和術前比降低了98%),術後6個月550cps(和術前比降低了91%),六個月比兩個月有微微的回升

LC-MS/MS can be used to evaluate bromhidrosis and the effects of surgery and is useful for assessing possible relapse. 質譜儀下的狐臭分子變化

the subdermal trimming technique illustrated in the original literature . 4–5-cm incision was made in the central pole of the crease and a subcutaneous pocket was then created. The elevated axillary flap was turned over with the fingertips; then, the trimming was performed under direct vision by using a scissor.

1. Although this technique caused lower recurrence rate and lesser complications in my clinical practice, a 4-5 cm linear scar was the main postoperative complaint, though not obvious in some cases. This may be because intervention through the narrow incision to open a pocket to clear the apocrine glands is difficult; although the skin is malleable, it has limitations and some places may still be inaccessible.
2. This may be because intervention through the narrow incision to open a pocket to clear the apocrine glands is difficult; although the skin is malleable, it has limitations and some places may still be inaccessible.
3.In order to decrease the scar length and sustain the clearance rate, I had an idea to modify the surgery by using two narrower incisions. We made two 1-1.5 cm incisions between the three aliquot boundaries of the armpit. Two subcutaneous pockets were made through both incisions and merged into a bigger pocket and glandular and subcutaneous tissues attaching to the dermis were removed carefully using only a scissors and direct vision. In this way, we could approach further from both openings and overcome the problem of insufficient ductility, with insignificant scarring.



we have observed high recurrences in our patients, such as with previous liposuction for accessory breast or trans-axillary breast augmentation, although these kinds of patients only occupied few in our bromhidrosis surgeries. We are curious about it and suspect the apocrine glands and superficial fascia complex are destroyed and not intact on the side of the skin flap after iris scissor dissection. This is why some of the glands are instead separated and attached toward the side of the subcutaneous tissues.
We could deduce that the previous axillary surgery may destroy the superficial fascia complex and make the plane disoriented. The apocrine glands not easily seen on the side of subcutaneous tissue after dissection is found abundant on the ones who had undergone axillary surgery before. Although many surgeons are aware of the importance of clearing the apocrine glands from the skin flap to reduce the risk of malodour recurrence, glands located in the subcutaneous tissue are easily neglected in patients who have previously undergone axillary surgery and these glands may also make a minor contribution to recurrence. Therefore, surgeons must consider the presence of apocrine glands both on the skin flap and on the subcutaneous adipose in order to achieve the best outcomes. However, we do not recommend that operators take an unnecessary amount of tissue, as this might increase the risk of hematoma and subsequent skin necrosis. Instead, we suggest that they remove the suspected glands in the subcutaneous adipose after careful inspection.

臨床的操作上,我們會發現因為復發重做手術,或以前做過抽脂副乳,經腋下隆乳患者來做手術,原先的apocrine gland – superficial complex被破壞掉了,再加上當時手術後會有纖維化的表現,再用鈍剪分離時,臨床的觀察皮下組織那一側會有一些粉紅色的組織,我們將其中一些組織剪除送化驗,可以發現裡面夾雜很多的頂漿腺體。因此上述的情況可以視為頂漿腺殘存的高風險狀況。